Wednesday, 22 March 2023

Making a wheel profile tool - turning the forming tool.

 Now that I had a pair of masters (see here) I could use them to make the forming tools themselves. Like the masters they're made from 16mm dia. silver steel.

The first job was to turn the outside diameter, just to true it up, then with the master tool set to centre height it could be plunged into the rod about 1mm from the front edge until the full form is below the outside diameter of the bar. This is the 2FS tool being formed;


Note the cutting compound, I used the type for tapping and dieing, which I'm not sure was the best choice. The work was turning using the slowest speed possible, and the finish wasn't as good as I'd hoped, the metal tending to tear rather than cut, especially on the wider Code 72 tool. A larger machine would have been a better choice, I felt that I was pushing the Unimat 3 to its limits on this job as far as rigidity was concerned.
I set the toolpost to sit on the right of the saddle whilst doing this, this way all of the force is going straight through the saddle;


When I turned the Code 72 tool I drilled a centre hole and used my rotating centre to help cut down vibration, this was because the code 72 tool is wider than the 2FS one and therefore puts more strain on both the machine and the workpiece;


Once the formers were turned they were both drilled out to 5.1mm, then cut/parted off before being turned to length using a watchmakers step collet leaving 1mm either side of the form;


The next stage followed the same pattern as the master, that is to file out a notch to make a cutting edge, stone the edge until smooth, and then harden and temper both cutters.
Here's a photo of both tools, mounted in the same holders that I used for the master tools.


Now I needed to test them both.


Paul.



Tuesday, 21 March 2023

Making a wheel profile tool - turning the master.

Despite owning several wheel profile tools bought from eBay I thought it might be fun to make my own. First of all I did some research, and found this article on the Manchester Model Railway Society website. The gist of it concerning making the profile tool is; turn a wheel to the correct profile in silver steel, convert that into a cutting tool, use that tool to cut a negative profile into another piece of silver steel, convert that into your forming tool. Silver steel can be easily worked then hardened and tempered making it ideal for making cutting tools.

I decided to make two tools, one to 2mm Finescale standards and one to NMRA RP25 Code 72, to cover both my 009 work and any future delving into 006. The relevant standards can easily be found online.

First of all I aquired some 16mm dia. silver steel, and turned the end to the basic dimensions of the wheel;



Then the 3 degree tread cone angle was turned, using my compound slide. There are two ways to get the correct angle for the flange (about 20 degrees), either by setting the turning tool to an angle to cut the flange angle at the same time as the tread is being turned, which is what I did on the 2FS wheel, or using the compound slide set to 20 degrees as shown below on the Code 72 wheel;


Once the basic form was finished a 5.1mm hole was then drilled in the centre and the wheel cut or parted off. Then using a watchmakers step collet the back face could be faced to length;


A simple mandrel was used to hold the wheels so the flange could be rounded off with a file and the wheel polished to a fine finish;


Both wheels ready to be made into cutters;


A centre line was scribed onto the back face and a cutting edge filed to just below the centre, to give some cutting rake (clearance);


Once I was happy with the shape the edge was ground, starting with fine oilstones and finishing with an Arkansas stone;


Then both cutters were hardened, by heating to bright red with a blowtorch and quenching in water, then tempered in the kitchen oven set to 200 degrees for 45 minutes to an hour. I then tickled up the cutting edge again with the Arkansas stone.
To use the cutters I made simple holders from 8mm square steel, drilled and tapped M5.


The next step will to use these masters to make a pair of forming tools.

Paul.


Monday, 20 March 2023

A new motor for my Unimat 3.

I've bit the bullet and bought a replacement motor for my Unimat 3. The original motor, despite being repaired a couple of times had a habit of tripping the mains, and of course Unimat motors are not continuously rated, so cannot be used for more than 8 minutes without rest. The lowest speed is 130rpm, a little too fast for some of the work that I intend to do. I do have a decent spare, but I wanted something better.
I found this one on eBay; 


It looks to be a scooter motor, with a control box on top. The single speed controller on top also doubles as an on/off switch;

Another view of it fitted;


Speed range using one belt (no idler pulley) is a claimed 20 to 2400rpm, although I'm not sure if that's at the motor or spindle.



 So, is it any good. Well, yes and no. It's nicely put together and smooth running, and adjusting the speed without swapping belts is nice (although swapping belts didn't bother me) as is the ability to work without worrying about the motor overheating. But, at low speed under heavy load the motor has a habit of 'pulsing' or stuttering, which is a nuisance when using profile tools. As I wanted a low speed motor for such work I'm unsure just how useful this motor is going to be, time will tell. This is the second motor that I've had from the seller, the first one displayed the same characteristics so I had it swapped (I should point out that the seller was extremely helpful). It may be that I only use it for general work and try to find another solution when using profile tools.


Paul.